Coronavirus Equities Blog

US Retail Innovators to Prosper in Post-Coronavirus Recovery

19 May 2020

4 min read

James T. Tierney, Jr.| Chief Investment Officer—Concentrated US Growth

Anna Toshach, CFA| Senior Research Analyst—Concentrated Growth

Economic fallout from the coronavirus pandemic has battered a US retail industry already experiencing seismic change. But companies with effective, multichannel consumer models in place before the crisis will compound these advantages on the other side of it.

The US retail industry—from groceries to jewelry—has undergone major structural change over the last decade. Amazon’s dominance around product information, availability and convenience has long raised the bar on consumer expectations and continues to fundamentally shift how retailers view their store-to-customer relationships. For equity investors, select companies that have adapted well to these changes deserve a closer look.

Pandemic Store Shutdowns Reflect Legacy Problems

The sea change in how consumers shop has left many retailers behind. Since 2010, over 41,000 US retail locations have closed—40% more than over the prior 10 years, which included the global financial crisis of 2008–2009 (Display, left). And more stores will stay closed after the pandemic. Our analysis estimates that one in 10 of the roughly 108,000 stores run by the 74 largest retailers may never reopen in the post–COVID-19 world (Display, right). Before the crisis, this 10% permanent closure would likely have taken three years to reach.

More Stores to Stay Closed After the Pandemic

As of April 23, 2020
*Based on AllianceBernstein (AB) analysis of 74 largest US retailers with combined 2019 revenues of $885.3 billion and 107,946 locations
Source: Credit Suisse and AllianceBernstein (AB)

J.C. Penney, J.Crew and Neiman Marcus are clear testaments of what happens when retailers stick to old ways. Even when they lost money, these “anchor store” retailers got by with a core model of low fixed operating costs and a steady volume of in-store customers. This legacy brick and mortar model is not ideal in the new retail environment, and flat out can’t work in a global pandemic when you’re forced to turn away shoppers at the door. By late May, J.C. Penney, Neiman Marcus and J.Crew had all sought Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection.

Digital Consumer Experience Redefines Business Models

It’s not that everyone shops on the web. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that online purchases were less than 15% of total retail sales in 2019. But the shelter-in-place rules across the country pushed consumers to try online shopping, and the influence of this permanent and growing wave of ultra-connected consumers can’t be dismissed. At the very least, it requires brick-and-mortar retailers and branded manufacturers alike to rethink and modernize their business models to reach their consumers.

Retailers like Home Depot and Ulta Beauty have kept their competitive edge with a digital transformation in fulfillment operations, and customer interactions and experiences. Also, many name-brand companies such as Nike and Estée Lauder have embraced e-commerce to expand into direct-to-consumer models. This widens their distribution capacity for starters, while also supporting customer-centric innovation and product development down the road.

Retailer Fates Accelerated by the Coronavirus

COVID-19 will be a catalyst for the fates of many US retailers—winners and losers alike. We expect a huge leapfrog effect as market share shifts faster from struggling, physical-centric stores to nimble, omnichannel models. Trends that were expected to unfold over a decade by most estimates will now be compacted into just a few months, in our view.

Innovators Were Equipped for the Crisis…

Few predicted a pandemic, but retailers that made innovative improvements to address changes in the industry have been better placed to navigate the crisis. For instance, long-standing supply-chain adjustments have helped some move fast to fulfill online orders and accommodate home delivery demands. Innovative loyalty programs and social media strategies, meanwhile, have changed how these retailers engage with customers. And these moves have helped them push forward timely customer updates and gather feedback in the extended global shutdown.

Retailers built to last also prioritized investment in technology. Their shifts to cloud-based infrastructures, for instance, let their leaderships seamlessly connect with employees and, during the crisis, have ensured operational integrity in potentially chaotic work-from-home scenarios. Meanwhile, mechanization and robotics adopted in distribution centers can promote healthy employee social distancing with minimal disruption to operations and output. Most important, companies that had already adopted cross-channel distribution capabilities—including curbside pickup and home delivery— were able to maintain at least some sales volume while their physical stores yielded none.

…and Poised for Long-Term Success

As states begin to slowly ease stay-at-home restrictions, consumers are starting to venture out. No one knows how long it will take to get back to normal. But retailers who stayed ahead of the curve with omnichannel consumer models and other forward-looking strategies will continue to benefit from them well after the storm subsides, those who didn’t, won’t.

While retail earnings will not be encouraging during the shutdown, extreme dislocations frequently create a domino effect. The additional debt taken on by weaker players becomes life threatening and causes them to degrade the customer experience—exactly when they need to be enhancing it to recapture shoppers. Investors who can find retailers with healthier balance sheets and the right strategic infrastructure in place to cope with the industry’s transformation should be able to find solid sources of consistent long-term earnings growth when the recovery kicks in.

The views expressed herein do not constitute research, investment advice or trade recommendations and do not necessarily represent the views of all AB portfolio-management teams. Views are subject to revision over time.

About the Authors

James T. Tierney, Jr.

James T. Tierney, Jr. is Chief Investment Officer of Concentrated US Growth. Prior to joining AB in December 2013, he was CIO at W.P. Stewart & Co. Tierney began his career in 1988 in equity research at J.P. Morgan Investment Management, where he analyzed entertainment, healthcare and finance companies. He left J.P. Morgan in 1990 to pursue an MBA and returned in 1992 as a senior analyst covering energy, transportation, media and entertainment. Tierney joined W.P. Stewart in 2000. He holds a BS in finance from Providence College and an MBA from Columbia Business School at Columbia University. Location: New York

Anna Toshach, CFA

Anna Toshach is a Senior Research Analyst for Concentrated Growth. She joined AB in 2018 as a senior research analyst covering the consumer-discretionary sector. Prior to that, Toshach was a consumer sector manager on the US Core and Large-Cap Growth Equity team at OppenheimerFunds, where she also cofounded the company's Women in Investments network and initiated a corporate partnership with Girls Who Invest. Earlier in her career, she worked as a research analyst with the Fundamental Growth team at Wells Capital Management, covering the consumer sector across all market caps. Toshach holds a BS in business administration (cum laude) from Marquette University's Applied Investment Management Program. She is a CFA charterholder. Location: New York

This information is for exclusive use of the wholesale person to whom it is provided and is not to be relied upon by any other person. It is not intended for retail or public use and may not be further distributed without prior written consent of ABAL.
This webpage has been prepared by AllianceBernstein Australia Limited (“ABAL”)—ABN 53 095 022 718, AFSL 230 698. Information in this webpage is only intended for persons that qualify as “wholesale clients,” as defined by the Corporations Act 2001, and is not to be construed as advice. This webpage is provided solely for informational purposes and is not an offer to buy or sell securities. The information, forecasts and opinions set forth in this webpage have not been prepared for any recipient’s specific investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs. Neither this webpage nor the information contained in it are intended to take the place of professional advice.
You should not take action on specific issues based on the information contained in this webpage without first obtaining professional advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Projections, although based on current information, may not be realized. Information, forecasts and opinions can change without notice and ABAL does not guarantee the accuracy of the information at any particular time. Although care has been exercised in compiling the information contained in this webpage, ABAL does not warrant that this webpage is free from errors, inaccuracies or omissions. ABAL disclaims any liability for damage or loss arising from reliance upon any matter contained in this webpage except for statutory liability which cannot be excluded.
No reproduction of the materials on this webpage may be made without the express written permission of ABAL. This information is provided for persons in Australia only and is not being provided for the use of any person who is in any other country.